Political theory |
“Political philosophies are intellectual and
moral creations. They contain high ideals, easy slogans, dubious facts, crude
propaganda, and sophisticated theories.” -- C. Wright Mills Political theory is a never-ending conversation
among theorists. And while the greatest of the debates are never resolved,
the criticisms which the writers make of each other are always most vivid and
illuminating.... Politics is, after all, the most democratic of sciences. --
Andrew Hacker “All sorts of political activities are influenced
by the process of ‘change’ or ‘keep the situations as it is ‘whenever we want
to keep it situation as it is.’ Whenever we want to keep it situation as it
is, then our objective is to stop any bad change and when we are bringing
changes, then we want to get better. This means that all types of political
activities are effected by ‘Better’ or ‘Bad’ thoughts but behind both these
lies the thought for good.” --- Leo Tolstoy |
|
State "The State is the keystone of the social
arch. It moulds the form and substance of the myriad human lives with whose
destinies it is charged." --- Laski The state does not create law of its own will;
law exists prior to the state; the state grasps it and gives it a definite
shape. -- Robert M MacIver The state comes into the picture only when the
interests of one group encroach upon another. The state is only one of such
associations, meant to serve definite interests— its authority is limited
like its obligations. -- Robert M MacIver "The West" created the cultural concept
of "the East," which allowed the Europeans to suppress the peoples
of the Middle East, the Indian Subcontinent, and of Asia in general, from
expressing and representing themselves as discrete peoples and cultures. --
Edward Said (orientalism) |
Justice |
Justice Each person possess inviolability founded on the
principle of justice that even the welfare of entire society can not
override. –John Rawls If the society is not based on the principles of
justice it will neither have peace nor stability. --John Rawls Natural distribution is neither just nor unjust,
it is the institution of society controlled by human beings makes it just or
unjust. --- John Rawls "Each person is to have an equal right to
the most extensive total system of equal basic liberties compatible with a
similar system of liberty for all” – John Rawls Laws and institutions no matter how efficient and
well arranged must be abolished, if they are unjust. – John Rawls Justice can not be secured by isolated
individuals seeking personal profit but by those who create a deeper
commonality through shared selfunderstanding and mutual affection. - Michael
Sandel The well-being of the individual depends on the
good of his community and therefore, the recognition and protection of the
group or cultural rights of the community is not less important than the just
distribution of the freedom and equality rights to the individuals.-
--Charles Taylor Progressive taxation is bonded labour. It goes
against the principle of dignity.-- Robert Nozick State should be minimum. It should be limited to
the security against the use of force, theft and problems in implementing the
agreements. More than these work will nullify the rights of a person, so they
will be unjust. – Robert Nozick |
Equality |
“Equality is basically a process of equalization.
So first of all equality implies to the deficiency of special right.
Secondly, it implies that everyone should get enough opportunities for
growth.” --- Laski Inequality is multi-dimensional and the
elimination of one aspect of inequality often leads to the exaggeration of
other aspects of social, political and cultural inequalities. - - Bryan S
Turner ‘The purpose of society would be frustrated at
the outset if the nature of a mathematician met with identical response with
that of a bricklayer’. --- Laski The principle of equality, accordingly means that
whatever conditions are guaranteed to me in the form of rights shall also and
in the same measure be guaranteed to others and that whatever rights are
given to others shall also be given to me’. –Ernest Barker The right to equality proper is a right to the
equal satisfaction of basic human needs, including the need to develop and
use capacities which are specifically human’ – D D Raphael Equal resources means the possibility of having
equitable resources so that everyone can carry out their conception of what
is good or well being.-- Ronald Dworkin Equality before law does not necessarily mean
that the law will treat all alike, but rather it determines that the law will
be within the reach of everybody. –J R Lucas Nobody will be small enough that he will be
unable to take the shelter of law and nobody will be big enough that he will
not be accountable to law. ---- J.R. Lucas Political equality means the authority which
exerts that power must be subject to rules of democratic governance. – Laski “If we want to maintain the political stability
and democratic form of government then we have to bring economic equality by
appropriate distribution of land, reforms in tax process and extension of
education facilities.” --Robert Dahl ‘By equality we should understand that not the
degree of power and riches be absolutely identical for everybody, but that no
citizen be wealthy enough to buy another and none poor enough to be forced to
sell himself.’ ---- Rousseau In the country in which wealth and means of
production are in the hands of some limited people, there money completely
over powers the politics, culture educational institutes and judiciary. –
Laski From the fact that people are very different, it
follows that if we treat them equally, the result must be inequality in their
actual position and that the only way to place them in an equal position
would be to treat them differently. –Hayek |
Liberty |
Liberty Liberty demands that none should be placed at the
mercy of others. By securing opportunities for all to be their best selves,
liberty makes equality real. Without liberty, equality lapses into dull
uniformity. –R H- Tawney Human consciousness postulates liberty; liberty
involves rights; rights demand the state. -- T H Green 'Nature has placed mankind under the governance
of two sovereign masters, pain and pleasure'. -Jeremy Bentham Individual tends to equilibriate himself with his
social environment by adaptation, and by inheritance of that adaptation,
until he attains, in a perfect equilibrium.-- Herbert Spencer ( concept of
negative liberty) An interest in liberty begins when men have
ceased to be overwhelmed by the problem of sheer existence; it is when they
have a chance of leisure, economic sufficiency and leisure for thought, these
are primary conditions of free man.—Laski An interest in liberty begins when men have
ceased to be overwhelmed by the problem of sheer existence; it is when they
have a chance of leisure, economic sufficiency and leisure for thought, these
are primary conditions of free man. -- R H- Tawney There is only one solution of liberty and it lies
in equality. Liberty without equality can degenerate into a license of the
few.’ --- Pollard Whatever claims be made in the name of equality,
it cannot be viewed in isolation, for the principle stands by the principles
of liberty and fraternity. – Ernest Barker “We are entering an era of political equality.
But economically and socially we remain a deeply unequal society. Unless we
resolve this contradiction, inequality will destroy our democracy.” ---Dr. B
R Ambedkar |
Rights |
Rights “Rights are those circumstances of human life
without which, usually a person cannot do the best development of his
personality. – Laski “This is that power of working of a man to
achieve his objectives which is defines by the social community on the
condition that he will do the welfare of the community also through these
works.” -- T.H. Green Legal right is such a benefit which is recognized
and secured by the legal rule and to follow it is a legal duty.” – Salmond “Right is such a claim of the individual which is
recognized by the society and is implemented by the state” – Bosanke To help in the development of the personal power
of the individual is the ultimate goal and supreme political value of the
state.” –Ernest Baker An individual is boar with certain rights by
birth. This means that these are not dependent on society or state. These
rights are given by the God to his children as he gives them eye, nose, ear,
hand etc. --John Lock Restrained government is the best way to protect
rights. -- John Lock “There can be but one supreme power, which is the
legislative, to which all the rest are and must subordinate, yet the
legislative being only a fiduciary power to act for certain ends, there
remains still in the people a supreme power to remove or alter the legislative when they find the legislative act
contrary to the trust reposed in them.” — John Locke “Every rights has to prove its reason in some
such objectives of the society which cannot be achieved without rights. --T H
Green “Rights, properly so called, are the creatures of
law properly so called; real laws give birth to real rights. -- Jeremy
Bentham People use right, not only as the members of the
state but as member of society also. Thus, to limit the right to only state
is to destroy the personality of an individual and its protection. – Laski Rights are not universal, these are limited to
the time and circumstances and are related to the specific social group. The
basis of rights is a historical process instead of intellect and tolerance
and a specific individual has no role in its construction. ---Historical
theory of rights "Men must learn to subordinate their
self-interest to the common welfare. The privileges of some must give way
before the rights of all."—Laski “Real rights are the conditions of the social
welfare and the reason of the various rights is one the fact that what role
they play for the coordinated development of the society” -- Hobbhouse “Rights are those circumstances of social life,
without which a person cannot attain his best – Laski Main source of rights is the rule of Natural
Right of self-ownership which means that every individual should be
considered as a means in itself. – Nozick Every person has a personal free area in which
there should no interference without his consent. ---Nozick There is no need to do welfare of the poor from
the things produced by the able people because” if I have complete right on
myself, then a sole owner of my capability and the produce made by my
capability.” Thus, it is wrong to re-distribute these sources by tax process.
–Nozick Rights are necessary conditions without which no
individual can in general seek to be at his best. – Herold Laski Every state is known by the rights it maintains.
– Herold Laski The social order which is not based on claims of
person is based on sand. – Herold Laski |
|
Democracy It is also on social system which having given
permission to select major part of population, governments post candidature
and given opportunity to affects main decisions. ---S M Lipset Democratic form is such on institutional
management of reaching of political decision that gives on opportunity to get
his general interest by selecting their representative. Democracy is only a instrument of, selection of
government, to rule or make law by different methods and taking political
decision. – Macpherson In a democracy, political decisions are taken by
the 'leadership', not by the people themselves; and there is a free
competition among the leaders for winning people's votes. -- Joseph A.
Schumpeter |
Power, ideology and legitimacy |
Power, ideology, legitimacy "Political power, properly to called, is
merely the organized power of one class for oppressing another,"
-----Engels “There is a general inclination of all mankind, a
perpetual and restless desire of power after power that ceased only in
death.” --Hobbes "The proper scope of political science is
not the study of the state or of any other specific institutional complex,
but the investigation of all associations insofar as they can be shown to
exemplify the problem of power" ------Frederick Watkins "It is with power in society that political
science is primarily concerned—its nature, basis, processes, scope and
results ... The 'focus of interest' of the political scientist is clear and
unambiguous; it centres on the struggle to gain or retain power, to exercise
power or influence over others, or to resist that exercise" ----------
William A. Robson “ Political science is 'the study of the shaping
and sharing of power” H. Lasswell and A. Kaplan “Power denotes the ability of a person to fulfil
his desires or to achieve his objectives” -- Bertrand Russell “Power is 'the ability to get one's wishes
carried out despite opposition” -- H.V. Wiseman The question of power cannot be evaded or brushed
aside, because it is the key question determining everything in a
revolution’s development, and in its foreign and domestic politics” – Lenin “The passing of state power from one class to
another is the first principal, the basic sign of revolution, both in
strictly scientific and in the practical political meaning of the term”. –
Lenin "Where genuine power is absent, violence may
emerge to fill the gap." -- Hannah Arendt “Only power but never violence can create legitimate
authority” --Hannah Arendt ‘Power is everywhere’, diffused and embodied in
discourse, knowledge and ‘regimes of truth’. -- Michel Foucault ‘Power is everywhere’ and ‘comes from everywhere’
so in this sense is neither an agency nor a structure. Instead it is a kind
of ‘metapower’ or ‘regime of truth’ that pervades society, and which is in
constant flux and negotiation. -- Michel Foucault “Ideology is a false consciousness” -- Karl Marx “The ideas of the ruling class are in every epoch
the ruling ideas” -- Karl Marx “Ideology is the characteristic of
totalitarianism; it has nothing to do in an open society” -- Karl Popper ‘‘In political activity men sail a boundless and
bottomless sea’’ -- Michael Oakeshott “The strongest is never strong enough to be
always the master unless he transforms strength into right and obedience into
duty.” --- Rousseau Rule was legitimate only when it operated to the
benefit of the whole society rather than in the selfish interests of the
rulers. – Aristotle “Power is the ability to get one’s wishes carried
out despite opposition”. -- H V Wiseman “Power as the capacity to command services or
compliance of others” -- Robert M MacIver |
Political Ideologies |
Liberalism Positive freedom consists in acting according to
reason, achieving self-realization or self-perfection. ---Thomas Hill Green An individual is free when he has the capacity to
fulfill the law of his being. --Thomas Hill Green |
|
“Success lies in a steady advance than in the
possibilities offered by a catastrophic crash”. -- Eduard Bernstein "For the right moment you must wait, as
Fabius did, most patiently, when warring against Hannibal, though many
censured his delays; but when the time comes you must strike hard, as Fabius
did, or your waiting will be in vain and fruitless." --Eduard Bernstein |
Marxism |
“Everything is and is not, for everything is
fluid, is constantly changing, constantly coming into being and passing away.
All is flux and nothing stays still. Nothing endures but change.” –Engels 'Matter' (and not the idea) was the essence of
universe, and that social institutions were the manifestation of changing
material conditions. – Marx First premise of all human existence, and
therefore of all history, is that men must be in a position to live in order
to be able to “make history”. -- Marx |
Feminism |
Feminism I do not want women to have power over men, but
power over themselves – Simone de Beauvoir "One is not born, but rather becomes, a
woman." -- Simone de Beauvoir Femininity is a construction of civilization, a
reflection not of “essential” differences in men and women but of differences
in their situation. -- Simone de Beauvoir Human beings are motivated by powerful emotions,
their ‘will’ rather than the rational mind, and in particular by what he
called the ‘will to power’. -- Friedrich Nietzsche |
“Each nation is animated by its collective
spirit, its Volksgeist, a product of its unique history, culture and
particularly language. Communities are therefore organic or natural entities,
shaped not by the calculations and interests of rational individuals but by
innate loyalties and emotional bonds forged by a common past. -- Johann
Gottfried Herder “If the testing ground of human existence is
competition and struggle, then the ultimate test is war, ‘an unalterable law
of the whole of life” ---Hitler “War is to men what maternity is to women.”
---Mussolini ‘Capitalism is a system by which capital uses the
nation for its own purposes. Fascism is a system by which the nation uses
capital for its own purposes.’ -----Oswald Mosley ‘Everything for the state; nothing against the
state; nothing outside the state.’ -------Mussolini Indian Political thinker |
|
|
‘For me truth is the sovereign principle which
includes numerous other principles. -- M K Gandhi Where there is Truth, there is also is knowledge
which is true. Where there is no Truth, there can be no true knowledge. -- M
K Gandhi Socialism is a beautiful word and so far as I am
aware in socialism all the members of society are equal none low, none high.
-- M K Gandhi The individual has a soul but the state is a
soulless machine, the stale can never be weaned away from violence to which
it owes its existence” It can never be weaned away from violence because its
basis has been force." -- M K Gandhi The state is not an end in itself, but a means of
enabling people to better their conditions in every department of life. -- M
K Gandhi “I look upon on increase in the power of the
state with the greatest fear, because although while apparently doing good by
minimizing exploitation, it does the greatest harm to mankind by destroying
individuality, which lies at the root of all progress. -- M K Gandhi ‘Democracy is something that gives the weak the
same as the strong” ---- M K Gandhi |
|
Democratic society is a prerequisite of a
democratic government. -- Dr. B R Ambedkar “Democracy is not merely a form of government. It
is essentially an attitude of respect and reverence towards fellowmen” ----
Dr. B R Ambedkar We must make our political democracy a social
democracy as well. Political democracy cannot last unless there lies at the
lease of it social democracy”. ------ Dr. B R Ambedkar |
|
Justice is proper stationing and non-interference
in each others work. ----Plato Covenants without swords are but mere words. –
Hobbes A government which violates its limitations is
not worthy of obedience. ---John Locke |
Machiavelli |
Men are ungrateful, fickle, deceitful, cowardly
and avaricious.” –Machiavelli “Men love at their pleasure, but fear at the
pleasure of the prince, who should therefore depend upon that which in his
own, not upon that which is of others. Yet he may be feared without being
hated if he refrains from touching their property and their woman kind of his
subjects, and if he avoid bloodshed excepting when there is good cause and
manifest justification for it is in as much as men more easily forget the
loss of their father than of their property.” –Machiavelli “The end of the state is material prosperity.”
---Machiavelli The ruler must imitate the fox and lion, for the
lion cannot protect himself from the traps and the fox cannot defend himself
from wolves”. ---Machiavelli “The great majority of mankind are satisfied with
appearances, as though they were realities, and are often even more
influenced by the things that seem than by those that are. ---Machiavelli |
Aristotle |
State come into existence for the sake of good
life and continues for the sake of good life.-------Aristotle State is highest of all associations.
-------Aristotle Man is by nature a political animal.
-------Aristotle “The state is by nature clearly prior to the
family and the individual, since the whole is of necessity prior to the part”
-------Aristotle It is unjust to treat equals unequally, it is
unjust to treat unequals equally. –Aristotle. “For that some should rule and others be ruled is
a thing not only necessary, but expedient; from the hour of their birth, same
are marked out for subjection other for rule”. --Aristotle (Politics) “The rule of law is preferable to that of a
single citizen: even if it be the better course to have individuals ruling,
they should be made law-guardians or ministers of the laws”. ------Aristotle ‘The goodness in the sphere of politics is
justice, and justice contains what tends to promote the common interest.”
---Aristotle Inequality, arose when equals were treated
unequally, and unequals equally. ------Aristotle Plato was a friend; Truth was a greater friend’.
–Aristotle The authority of statesman is different from the
authority of master. ------Aristotle The good of the many had to be based on the good
of the self. ------Aristotle “The many are more incorruptible than the few;
they are like the greater quantity of water which is less easily corrupted
than a little.” ― Aristotle, Law is a reason without passion. ---Aristotle Good ruler ought to be worldly-wise rather than
wise in the world of ideas. ---Aristotle |
|
The ideal is nothing else than the material world
reflected by the human mind, and translated into forms of thought. —Karl Marx “It is not the consciousness of men that
determines their existence, but, on the contrary, their social existence
determines their existence”. –Marx “The history of all hitherto existing society is
the history of class struggles”. –Marx “Freeman and slave, patrician and plebeian, lord
and serf, guild-master and journeyman, in a word, oppressor and oppressed,
stood in constant opposition to one another”. --Marx “The ideas of the ruling class are in every epoch
the ruling ideas. –Marx |
|
Everyone who receives the protection of society
owes a return for the benefit.—John Stuart Mill “Over himself, over his own body and mind, the
individual is sovereign. – J S Mill “If all mankind minus one were of one opinion,
mankind would be no more justified in silencing that one person than he, if
he had the power, would be justified in silencing mankind”. –J S Mill Men should not be trusted with absolute power.
Such absolute power within the family and marriage only led to brutalization
of women. – J S Mill “It is only by the collision of adverse opinion
that the remainder of the truth has any chance of being supplied”. –J S Mill “All the worth which the human being possess, all
spiritual reality, he possess” only through the state”. –Hegel The history of the world is none other than the
progress of the consciousness of freedom. – Hegel |
Views on state |
Aristotle: the purpose of the state is
mainly ethical. The state is ' a community of equals, aiming at the best life
possible.' Hobbes: the purpose of the state to
maintain order and protect the people and protect the right of property. Locke: regards that the end of
Government is the preservation of lives, liberties and estates. Rousseau: the state is a ' social contract'
to fulfil the ' general will Bentham: believes the state exists to
secure the greatest good of the greatest number. Herbert Spencer:
consider the state as ' Joint-stock protection company for mutual assurance.' Marx expects the state to "wither
away' after establishing' classless society.' · Laski the state is ' a fellowship of
men. Its aim is ' enrichment of common life'. The aim of a state to be the
greatest available welfare for the whole population and not for a class. |
Comments
Post a Comment